November 15th, 2012
Reflective Essay on the Film [Ben X]
Mr. Garrioch / English Composition
11b4 111150 Ho InHee
Belgium film [Ben X] deals with a highly universal issue:
bullying. The outcast being bullied in this film is Ben, a teenage boy suffering
from Asperger syndrome. He undergoes every spiteful mischief and even physical
abuse done by his classmates, without a single successful defiance. The only
way out he has is online game ArchLord,
where neither appearance nor sociability is required. He is an outcast in his
school, who finds comfort in his fake world of online game.
Bullying is a
social problem. Outcasts created by the bullying majority exist in any sort of
society, not to mention schools full of immature and impetuous teenagers. It of
course seems logical that companionship cannot exist without ostracism, and
therefore outcasts are inevitable for certain society to exist. Anyone
distinguishes between crimson and red, scarlet and orange. On a generally red
piece of paper, people can tell which part is red and which isn’t. But let
there be one blue dot on that reddish paper. It becomes meaningless to
distinguish reddish from red any longer because blue is the apparently least
red color on that paper. Crimson, scarlet, and orange all go within a boundary
of red, with the existence of blue. Without that blue dot, however, the ‘generally’
red paper isn’t just red anymore. This applies similarly to the real world.
Excluding the most different minority brings strong solidarity to the society,
letting otherwise substantial differences among insiders become negligible.
Clearly,
bullying isn’t so conspicuous any more. America’s Jim Crow laws and Nazi’s
Holocaust has become a disgrace in human history. No more color bar is
admittable. Women, children, blacks, Asians, Mormons, and any former minorities
all have equal opportunities, equal rights today. ‘Equality’ is an important keyword,
and excluding certain group from the majority, depriving rights and suppressing
them is against this mainstream value. People with innate disadvantages are not
those who are to be left subordinate but those who are to be aided and
assisted. Though people still crave to pursue the stability and comfort they
get from ostracism in the very deep, at least on surface they all endeavor to
help the weak and do virtue.
What we see in
this Belgium film [Ben X] is,
ironically, undisguised ostracism and naked violence. The classmates have Ben
stand on the table and take off his pants so that anyone in the classroom can
see him mortified. They videotape this vicious prank, upload on internet so
that anyone can access this video. Ben’s self-styled ‘friends’ beat Ben nastily
by one tying his both hands and the other punching his stomach. They further
extort Ben’s newest Nokia and force him to swallow their spit. The classmates’
open bullying acts severely on Ben’s state of mind, driving him almost
schizophrenic. But why is this school violence so explicit?
There
is a common perspective viewing teenagers: immature, impulsive, irrational, and
rebellious. Adolescence is a period between childhood and adulthood. Teens
witness irregularities and learn the reality, but are yet vulnerable and
somewhat naïve. They fight against conventions and undergo identity crisis. In
many ways, teens are insecure and unstable. .And this conception, true or not,
allows teens to behave in the way they want. Our society is especially generous
to teens. While adults chide and coax young children to behave, they indulge
teens and condone all their misdemeanors. They often reproach teens for
rebellious and defiant attitudes, but that’s all. They do not endeavor too hard
to scold teens, to shape them up, because teens are insecure and rebellious.
They do not punish teens’ misdeeds too harshly because teens are immature. Beating
someone on the head is something to be severely reproached for a child and
something to be legally punished for an adult. But for teenager, it is
something we have to overlook, or otherwise something a parent has to beg for
forgiveness. Teenager is expected to behave in such way and isn’t to be
punished. And teenagers, aware of the impunity they have, let themselves behave
more irresponsibly, impulsively, and irrationally.
Think of why our
society is in general progressing (at least outwardly) to a more sophisticated,
civilized one, yet the teens’ society, school, is stagnated on uncivilized,
rudimentary level where the members behave primitively.Teens regard
themselves, and are regarded immature and rebellious being. Their misbehaviors
are rationalized in society. They easily go unpunished for their conducts.
Bullying is
indeed a social problem. It corresponds to the desire to form a stable, strong
community, to the instinctive want to be belonged. But
there is a reason why bullying is most notable in school. It is that teenage is
an age when bullying, no matter how violent and cruel it gets, is natural, and
thus, okay. No, it is that people all believe so. No violence is okay. When
someone acts violence (physically, verbally, or in any way), regardless of the
age, he (or she) is to be chastised and punished. Excusing all his guilt does
not keep him guiltless nor penitent. Poor victims like Ben never disappear
unless teenagers are rightfully reproached and punished just like others.
Some good points in here - but they are buried in a lot of indirect discussion that is and isn't about the film. As I mentioned with the original Earthlings review and your paragraph about chocolate - stick to the REAL topic. For instance, this is a BIG detour that will derail your average reader:
답글삭제"On a generally red piece of paper, people can tell which part is red and which isn’t. But let there be one blue dot on that reddish paper. It becomes meaningless to distinguish reddish from red any longer because blue is the apparently least red color on that paper. Crimson, scarlet, and orange all go within a boundary of red, with the existence of blue."
What about the film and the review? You are a good writer with lots of unique thoughts, but know when and where to use them and when to keep things simple and straight forward. If you don't break that habit now you will get in trouble for it in university.
Anyways... some interesting stuff in here, but a simple approach would be much more in line with the assignment.