March 19th, 2013
James Joyce - Araby paragraph
Mr. Garrioch / World Lit.
12v1 111150 Ho In Hee
From a distance, James Joyce’s “Araby”
might appear to be a story of a boy’s disillusionment with reality. After all,
when the nameless narrator encounters a lady shopkeeper who is more interested
in two young men flirting with her, he finds his eyes “burned with anguish and
anger”. His fantasy about Araby as “Eastern enchantment” breaks when he
actually reaches there, by its dark look and by feigned manners and flirtations
of people in the bazaar. Such disappointment brings him a realization of how
deluded his ideal has been. However, on the other hand, the narrator’s anger is
also rooted himself as well. From the very beginning, the narrator’s love
toward Mangan’s sister is depicted as more holy than physical. The narrator
portrays his deep crush on her when he says “her name sprang to my lips at
moments in strange prayers and praises” or “(I) murmured “O love! O love!” many times”. This contrasts his uninvolvement in
the Irish Christian society alluded in phrases like “I went into the back
drawing-room in which the priest had died”. The boy’s epiphany of his self
contradiction takes place when he confronts a lady shopkeeper flirting with two
young men and fake kindness, when he “sees himself as a creature driven and
derided by vanity”. He comes to know his love was not simply platonic, as he
depicted, but physical. Therefore, it is perhaps more accurate to assume that “Araby”
extends beyond anguish over the outer world. The narrator, indulged in an
illusion towards both the world and in himself, realizes the true selfish and
affected mind as he goes through emotional crash. In this sense, the narrator’s
disillusionment is not simply rooted in frustration towards the society but
also in himself.
Good work. For the most part, clear and easy to follow, referencing the text with strong evidence. There are a few bumpy places where you forget something small (rooted himself etc.). In a small assignment like this, I hope for something "close" to perfection.
답글삭제All in all, nice job.