March 30th, 2013
Gabriel Marquez – A Very Old Man with
Enormous Wings
Mr. Garrioch / World Lit
12v1 111150 Ho In Hee
“It always amuses me that the biggest praise for my work comes for the
imagination, while the truth is that there’s not a single line in all my work
that does not have a basis in reality.” –Gabriel
Marquez
Gabriel Marquez
is an eminent Latin American writer largely known for his magic realism pieces.
Magic realism, also known as magical realism, is a literary movement in which the
writer confronts reality and tries to untangle it, to discover what is
mysterious in things, in life, in human acts. (Luis Leal, Magical Realism in
Spanish American Literature. Magical Realism. Ed. Zamora and Faris) Though he
used many apparently unrealistic and magical elements, Marquez had certain
realistic issues he wanted to portray via his stories. A Very Old Man with
Enormous Wings, one of his famous short stories, also takes real problems
of the world.
The story
illustrates how people judge the supernatural. The old man with wings is a
stranger to the town. No one of the townspeople can assure who the man is. The
neighbor woman of Pelayo claims the man is an angel. But the man, with “a few
faded hairs left on his bald skull, and a very few teeth in his mouth”, and “huge
buzzard wings, dirty and half-plucked”, in no sense accords with the angel they
imagine, with a pure white dress and silky blonde hair. Thus they start
treating the angel more like an animal than a holy creature. Moreover, Father
Gonzaga doubts the man being an angel because in his measure, angel should speak
Latin. Whereas humans are not omniscient and might not be able to fully understand
the supernatural, the people in A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings
appraise the angel on their worldly and imperfect criteria.
Readers can
further get a sense of people’s superiority they feel over the old man. When
Pelayo and Elisenda first find the old man with the wings, he regards the man
as a “nightmare”. Even after they hear from a neighbor woman that the man is an
angel, Pelayo “drags him out of the mud and locked him up with the hens in the
wire chicken coop.” That night, when Pelayo’s child wakes up without a fever,
he feels “magnanimous” and “decides to put the angel on a raft for three days.”
If the angel were a human being, Pelayo would not let that man on a raft and
regard that as a behavior of magnanimity. Nor would Pelayo let the angel whom
he truly regards as angel sleep on a raft when he feels magnanimous. Such
decision to put the angel on a raft is driven not from Pelayo’s respect for the
angel.
Yet Pelayo is
not the only one to regard the angel as a weak inferior. At the end of the
story, when the angel loses his popularity but still does not leave the house,
Elisenda gets “exasperated and unhinged”. The whole neighborhood has fun with
the angel “without the slightest reverence”, as if he weren’t a supernatural
creature but a circus animal. Later on, the neighborhood and hundreds of people
from distance away come to see this unusual being, as if it is a zoo animal.
Elisenda takes benefit by charging five cents admission to see the angel. Every
single character in the story does not show, as the author writes, the “slightest
reverence” to this injured and aged winged man but rather a superiority we feel
over animals.
But the old man
is not the only supernatural being presented in the story. Numerous people from
faraway all visit Pelayo’s house to see the caged angel. The popularity of this
angel seems like it would last for a while until the spider woman appears. The
spider woman claims that she turned into a tarantula for not obeying her
parents. This woman, who clearly knows (or assures she knows) how she became a
tarantula, quickly fascinates the majority much more than the unidentified and
wordless old angel does and the man is soon forgotten. But the people desire for
a great lesson from the tarantula girl – such as to never disobey parents’ words.
It is rather plausible to say that they are chasing anything unusual and
surprising, just like a group of reporters running after hot issues for eye-catching
headline. Marquez himself received public’s attention after publishing his
novel One Hundred Years of Solitude. This novel won him many prestigious
awards such as Noble Prize and Romulo Garllegos Prize as well as great
popularity and critics’ acclaims. However, Marquez goes to live in Spain. He
said that his book was not worthy of such attention and he knew the vain of
such popularity. In this sense, the old angel in his book may be a portrayal of
himself who is overburdened by the unwanted public attention.
There are certain words that are hard to juxtapose with each other. ‘Magic’
and ‘Realism’ are some very typical ones. ‘Magic’, as Merriam-Webster defines,
is the ‘use of means believed to have supernatural power over natural forces’,
whereas ‘Realism’ is a literary movement basically focusing on replicating the
true nature of reality. But this seemingly self-contradicting word has been
used for decades to characterize a renowned novelist named Gabriel Garcia
Marquez. As in A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings, Marquez effectively conveys
realistic themes through unrealistic characters.
+) I tried hard to not go over 900 words. The journal is solely about our second story only- and perhaps I should post another one about the handsomest drowned man later?
As said in class, you only have to chose one (or a contrast of both - which is a bit more interesting, in my opinion). Anyways, this is pretty solid, and there is nothing to complain about in terms of referencing the text, or offering insight. Don't shy away from some "I" from time to time, and it is okay to take some risks. While some students take too many risks in terms of what they deduce from the text, you might be playing a bit too safe at times, and relying on what professors say. In the future, I urge you to maintain your strong analysis (tight and succinct, as it is) while offering more your own insight as related to a strong "claim" - as was done with Araby. You have one here - with how common people with short and imperfect attention spans respect or fail to respect icons - but it could be a bit more pronounced early on.
답글삭제All in all, quite decent.